Laura Gottesdiener, An American Saddam Hussein? – War Is A Crime

This text initially appeared at To obtain TomDispatch in your inbox 3 times every week, click right here.

It’s been virtually 18 years of “infinite” warfare, carnage, the mass displacement of peoples, the destruction of cities… you already know the story. We all do… kinda… however more often than not it’s a story with out them. You seldom hear their voices. They’re not often attended to in our world. I’m interested by the Afghans, Iraqis, Syrians, Yemenis, Somalis, Libyans, and so forth who’ve borne the brunt of our endless wars. Yes, now and again there’s a hanging piece in the American media, as there was just lately in a joint investigation by the Bureau of Investigative Journalism and the New York Occasions of the slaughter of a mother and her seven youngsters (the youngest was 4 years previous) in an Afghan village brought on by an American JDAM missile (and initially denied by the U.S. army). It was one in every of a rising number of U.S. air strikes across that nation. In every of those items, you possibly can truly hear the pained voice of the husband, Masih Ur-Rahman Mubarez, who wasn’t there when the bomb hit and so lived to seek justice for his household. (“We have a saying: staying silent against injustice is a crime, therefore I will spread my voice throughout the world. I will talk to everyone, everywhere. I will not stay silent. But this is Afghanistan. If someone hears us, or not, we will still raise our voice.”)

Usually speaking, although, the time we People spend on the lives of those in lands that, in this century, we’ve had such a hand in turning into desperately failed or failing states is small indeed. I typically think about a subject that TomDispatch has coated virtually alone in these years: the best way, between 2001 and 2013, U.S. air power wiped out wedding ceremony parties in three nations throughout the Higher Middle East: Afghanistan, Iraq, and Yemen. (Using U.S. planes and weaponry, the Saudis have continued such grim slaughters in recent times in Yemen.)

You in all probability don’t keep in mind even one wedding ceremony get together being worn out by a U.S. air strike — the precise number was at the least eight — and I don’t blame you as a result of they didn’t get a lot attention here. One exception: the Murdoch-owned tabloid, the New York Publish, front-paged a drone strike on a caravan of automobiles heading for a marriage in Yemen in 2013 with this headline “Bride and Boom!”

I all the time imagine what would happen if an al-Qaeda- or ISIS-inspired suicide bomber took out an American wedding ceremony here, killing the bride or groom, visitors, even musicians (as then-Marine Main Common James Mattis’s forces did in Iraq in 2004). You already know the reply: there can be days of outraged 24/7 media consideration, together with interviews with weeping survivors, background tales of every type, memorials, ceremonies, and so on. However when it’s we who are the destroyers, not the destroyed, the news passes in a flash (if at all), and life (here) goes on, which is why TomDispatch regular Laura Gottesdiener’s submit right now is, to my thoughts, so special. She does exactly what the remainder of our media so seldom does: provides the unmediated voices of two young Iraqi peace activists — did you even know that there have been younger Iraqi peace activists? — discussing lives deeply affected by the American invasion and occupation of their country in 2003. Tom

Two Iraqi Peace Activists Confront a Trumpian World
As the Trump Administration Weighs War, Iraqis Put together a Carnival for Peace
By Laura Gottesdiener

There’s a darkish joke going round Baghdad lately. Noof Assi, a 30-year-old Iraqi peace activist and humanitarian employee, informed it to me by telephone. Our dialog takes place in late May after the Trump administration has announced that it might add 1,500 further U.S. troops to its Center Japanese garrisons.

“Iran wants to fight to get the United States and Saudi Arabia out of Iraq,” she began. “And the United States wants to fight to get Iran out of Iraq.” She paused dramatically. “So how about all of us Iraqis just leave Iraq so they can fight here on their own?”

Assi is among a era of younger Iraqis who lived most of their lives first underneath the U.S. occupation of their nation after which by way of the disastrous violence it unleashed, including the rise of ISIS, and who at the moment are warily eying Washington’s saber-rattling in the direction of Tehran. They couldn’t be more conscious that, ought to a battle erupt, Iraqis will virtually definitely find themselves once again caught within the devastating center of it.

In February, President Trump sparked ire by claiming that america would keep its army presence — 5,200 troops — and the al-Asad airbase in Iraq so as to “watch Iran.” In Might, the State Division then instantly ordered all non-emergency government staff to go away Iraq, citing obscure intelligence about threats of “Iranian activity.” (This so-called intelligence was promptly contradicted by the British deputy commander of the U.S.-led coalition preventing ISIS who claimed that “there’s been no increased threat from Iranian-backed forces in Iraq and Syria.”) A few days later, a rocket landed harmlessly in Baghdad’s closely fortified Inexperienced Zone, which homes the U.S. embassy. Iraqi Prime Minister Adel Abdul Mahdi then announced that he would send delegations to Washington and Tehran to attempt to “halt tensions,” while hundreds of unusual Iraqis rallied in Baghdad to protest towards the potential of their nation as soon as once more getting dragged right into a battle.

Much of American media protection of rising U.S.-Iranian tensions in these weeks, rife with “intel” leaked by unnamed Trump administration officials, bears a putting resemblance to the lead-up to the 2003 U.S. invasion of Iraq. As a current Al Jazeera piece — headlined “Is the US media beating the drums of war on Iran?” — put it bluntly: “In 2003, it was Iraq. In 2019, it’s Iran.”

Unfortunately, in the intervening 16 years, American protection of Iraq hasn’t improved much. Definitely, the Iraqis themselves are largely lacking in action. When, for example, does the American public hear about how female students in Iraq’s second largest city, Mosul, closely bombed and brought again from ISIS in 2017, have organized to restock the cabinets of the once-famed library on the College of Mosul, which ISIS militants set aflame throughout their occupation of the town; or how booksellers and publishers are reviving Baghdad’s world-renowned ebook market on Mutanabbi Road, destroyed by a devastating automotive bomb in 2007; or how, every September, tens of hundreds of young individuals now gather throughout Iraq to rejoice Peace Day — a carnival that started eight years in the past in Baghdad as the brainchild of Noof Assi and her colleague, Zain Mohammed, a 31-year-old peace activist who can also be the owner of a restaurant and efficiency area?

In other words, not often is the U.S. public allowed glimpses of Iraq that make warfare there appear much less inevitable.

Assi and Mohammed are properly accustomed not solely to such skewed illustration of their nation in our nation, but to the truth that Iraqis like them are missing in motion in American consciousness. They continue to be amazed, actually, that People might have triggered such destruction and ache in a country they proceed to know so little about.

“Years ago, I went to the United States on an exchange program and I discovered people didn’t know anything about us. Someone asked me if I used a camel for transportation,” Assi informed me. “So I returned to Iraq and I thought: Damn it! We have to tell the world about us.”

In late Might, I spoke with Assi and Mohammed separately by phone in English concerning the rising menace of one other U.S. conflict within the Middle East and their collective 20 years of peace work aimed toward undoing the violence wrought by the final two U.S. wars of their country. Under, I’ve edited and melded the interviews of those two pals so that People can hear a few voices from Iraq, telling the story of their lives and their commitment to peace within the years after the invasion of their nation in 2003.

Laura Gottesdiener: What first inspired you to start doing peace work?

Zain Mohammed: On the end of 2006, on December 6th, al-Qaeda-[in-Iraq, the precursor to ISIS] executed my dad. We are a small household: me and my mom and two sisters. My opportunities have been limited to 2 options. I was 19 years previous. I had simply finished highschool. So the choice was: I needed to to migrate or I had to grow to be a part of the system of militias and take revenge. That was the life-style in Baghdad at the moment. We emigrated to Damascus [Syria]. Then instantly, after about six months, when our paperwork was almost prepared for us to emigrate to Canada, I informed my mom, “I want to go back to Baghdad. I don’t want to run away.”

I went again to Baghdad at the end of 2007. There was an enormous automotive bombing in Karrada, the part of the town the place I used to stay. My pals and I made a decision to do something to tell our pals that we’ve got to work together to advertise peace. So, on December 21st, on International Peace Day, we held a small event in the identical place because the explosion. In 2009, I acquired a scholarship to the American University in Sulaymaniyah for a workshop about peace and we watched a film about Peace Day. At the finish of the film, there were flashes of many scenes from around the globe and, for only one second, there was our event in Karrada. This film was superb for me. It was a message. I went again to Baghdad and I spoke to one in every of my buddies whose father had been killed. I advised him it’s systematic: If he’s Shiite, he’ll be recruited by a Shiite militia for revenge; if he’s Sunni, he’ll be recruited by a Sunni militia or al-Qaeda for revenge. I informed him: we have now to create a third choice. By a third choice, I meant any choice besides preventing or emigrating.

I spoke to Noof and she or he stated we’ve to gather youth and manage a gathering. “But what’s the point?” I requested her. All we had was this concept of a third choice. She stated: “We have to collect youth and have a meeting to decide what to do.”

Noof Assi: When Baghdad was first built, it was referred to as the Metropolis of Peace. Once we first began talking to individuals, everyone laughed at us. A Metropolis of Peace celebration in Baghdad? It’ll by no means occur, they stated. At the moment, there were no occasions, nothing happened within the public parks.

Zain: Everyone stated: you’re crazy, we’re nonetheless in a warfare…

Noof: We didn’t have any funding, so we determined let’s mild candles, stand in the street, and tell those that Baghdad is known as the Metropolis of Peace. But then we grew into a gaggle of round 50 individuals, so we created a small pageant. We had zero finances. We have been stealing stationery from our workplace and utilizing the printer there.

Then we thought: Okay, we made some extent, but I don’t assume individuals will need to continue. But the youth came again to us and stated, “We enjoyed it. Let’s do it again.”

Laura: How has the pageant grown since then?

Noof: The first yr, round 500 individuals got here and most of them have been our families or kin. Now, 20,000 individuals attend the pageant. But our concept isn’t only concerning the pageant, it’s concerning the world that we create via the pageant. We literally do every part from scratch. Even the decorations: there is a group that makes the decorations by hand.

Zain: In 2014, we felt the first results when ISIS and this shit happened once more, however this time, on the societal degree, numerous groups have been beginning to work collectively, amassing cash and clothes for internally displaced individuals. Everyone was working collectively. It felt like a light-weight.

Noof: Now, the pageant occurs in Basra, Samawah, Diwaniyah, and Baghdad. And we’re hoping to broaden to Najaf and Sulaymaniyah. During the last two years, we’ve been working to create the primary youth hub in Baghdad, the IQ Peace Middle, which is house to totally different clubs: a jazz club, a chess club, a pets membership, a writing membership. We had a women-and-girls membership to debate their points inside the metropolis.

Zain: We had a whole lot of financial challenges because we have been a youth motion. We weren’t a registered NGO [non-governmental organization] and we didn’t need to work like a daily NGO.

Laura: What about different peace efforts in the city?

Noof: Prior to now few years, we’ve began seeing lots of totally different movements around Baghdad. After a few years of seeing solely armed actors, wars, and soldiers, young individuals needed to construct another image of the town. So, now, we’ve got numerous actions around schooling, well being, leisure, sports activities, marathons, ebook clubs. There’s a motion referred to as “I’m Iraqi, I Can Read.” It’s the most important pageant for books. Exchanging or taking books is free for everyone they usually usher in authors and writers to sign the books.

Laura: This isn’t exactly the picture that I think many People keep in mind when they consider Baghdad.

Noof: Someday, Zain and I have been bored within the workplace, so we started Googling totally different photographs. We stated, “Let’s Google Iraq.” And it was all pictures of the warfare. We Googled Baghdad: Similar factor. Then we googled something — it’s famous all over the world — the Lion of Babylon [an ancient statue], and what we found was a picture of a Russian tank that Iraq developed throughout Saddam [Hussein]’s regime that they named Babylon’s Lion.

I’m an Iraqi and I’m a Mesopotamian with that long historical past. We’ve grown up dwelling in a metropolis that’s previous and where each place, every road you cross, has a historical past to it, however the international media doesn’t speak about what’s occurring on these streets. They concentrate on what the politicians are saying and omit the remaining. They don’t show the actual image of the nation.

Laura: I need to ask you concerning the rising tensions between america and Iran, and how individuals in Iraq are responding. I know you could have your personal inner issues, so no matter Trump tweets on a given day won’t be the most important news for you…

Noof: Sadly, it’s.

Particularly since 2003, Iraqis haven’t been ones controlling our country. Even the government now, we don’t need it, however no one has ever asked us. We’re still paying with our blood while — I used to be reading an article about this a couple of months ago — Paul Bremer is now educating skiing and dwelling his simple life after ruining our nation. [In 2003, the Bush administration appointed Bremer head of the Coalition Provisional Authority, which ran occupied Iraq after the U.S. invasion and was responsible for the disastrous decision to disband Iraqi autocrat Saddam Hussein’s army.]

Laura: What do you consider the news that the U.S. is planning to deploy 1,500 extra troops to the Center East?

Zain: If they end up coming to Iraq, the place we’ve plenty of pro-Iranian militias, I’m afraid there might be a collision. I don’t need a collision. In a warfare between america and Iran, perhaps some troopers can be killed, however numerous Iraqi civilians will probably be, too, instantly and not directly. Truthfully, all the things that has happened since 2003 is strange to me. Why did the USA invade Iraq? After which they stated they needed to go away and now they need to come back? I can’t understand what the USA is doing.

Noof: Trump is a businessman, so he cares about money and the way he’s going to spend it. He’s not going to do one thing until he’s positive that he’s going to get one thing in return.

Laura: That reminds me of the best way Trump used the rising tensions in the region so as to bypass Congress and push via an $8 billion arms cope with Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates.

Noof: Precisely. I mean, he was asking Iraq to pay the USA back for the costs of the U.S. army occupation in Iraq! Can you think about? So that’s how he thinks.

Laura: Amid these rising tensions, what’s your message to the Trump administration — and to the American public?

Zain: For the U.S. authorities, I’d say that, in each struggle, even for those who win, you lose something: money, individuals, civilians, tales… We now have to see the opposite aspect of warfare. And I’m positive we will do what we would like without warfare. For the U.S. public: I feel my message is to push towards struggle, even towards financial conflict.

Noof: For the U.S. authorities I might tell them: please thoughts your personal enterprise. Depart the rest of the world alone. For the American individuals I might tell them: I’m sorry, I understand how you’re feeling being in a country run by Trump. I used to be dwelling beneath Saddam’s regime. I still keep in mind. I have a colleague, she’s American, and the day Trump gained the elections she got here into the workplace crying. And a Syrian and I have been within the workplace together with her and we informed her: “We’ve been there before. You will survive.”


On September 21st, Noof Assi, Zain Mohammed, and hundreds of other young Iraqis will crowd a park along the Tigris River to rejoice the eighth annual Baghdad City of Peace Carnival. In the USA, in the meantime, we’ll virtually definitely still be dwelling underneath the Trump administration’s almost day by day threats of warfare (if not conflict itself) with Iran, Venezuela, North Korea, and god is aware of the place else. A current Reuters/Ipsos public opinion poll exhibits that People increasingly see one other warfare in the Middle East as inevitable, with greater than half of those polled saying it is “very likely” or “somewhat likely” that their nation would go to conflict with Iran “within the next few years.” But as Noof and Zain know full nicely, it’s all the time attainable to seek out an alternative choice…

Laura Gottesdiener, a TomDispatch regular, is a contract journalist and former Democracy Now! producer presently based mostly in northern Lebanon.

Comply with TomDispatch on Twitter and be a part of us on Facebook. Take a look at the most recent Dispatch Books, John Feffer’s new dystopian novel (the second within the Splinterlands collection) Frostlands, Beverly Gologorsky’s novel Every Body Has a Story, and Tom Engelhardt’s A Nation Unmade by War, as well as Alfred McCoy’s Within the Shadows of the American Century: The Rise and Decline of U.S. International Energy and John Dower’s The Violent American Century: War and Terror Since World War II.

Copyright 2019 Laura Gottesdiener